Over 35 Years in Business Over 35 Years in Business
Diamond Concierge Diamond Concierge
Lifetime Diamond Upgrades Lifetime Diamond Upgrades
Custom CAD Jewelry Design Custom CAD Jewelry Design
Top Designers Top Designers
Financing Financing

Why Good Old Gold


Diamond Specific

*1 Year Buy-Back on Many Diamonds

*Lifetime Trade-Up on Many Diamonds

*10 - 30 Day Money Back Guarantee Options

*Access to 100k+ Diamonds in our Suppliers’ Inventories

*Our Custom Cut Services

*Popular Cuts as well as a Unique Diamond Selection

*Conflict-Free Diamonds in Accordance with the Kimberley Act

*We Buy Diamonds and Gold

*Sell Your Diamond Using Our Consignment Program

*Useful Services for Comparing the Brilliance of Diamonds like HD Videos


Looking for a Better Deal on a Diamond You’ve Seen Advertised Elsewhere? Just Ask!

We Will Beat Other Retailers List Price As Long As We Have Access to the Same Diamond.


Jewelry Specific

*2-Week Money Back Guarantee on Existing Jewelry

*Large In-House Selection Plus Access to Tons of Jewelry Not Listed on Our Website Upon Request

*Impressive New and Estate Jewelry Selection

*Custom Made CAD Jewelry

*Large Selection of Engagement Rings

*Select Designer Ring Trade-Up Benefits

Good Old Gold Product Manufacture Guarantee

*In-House Jewelers Available to Repair, Customize, Clean, and Polish Your Jewelry

*Jewelry Appraisals

*Watch Battery and Repairs

*Ear Piercings

*Our Consignment Jewelry Program

*We Buy Jewelry and Gold


Additional Benefits


*Free Domestic Shipping On Purchases, Fully Insured


Interest-Free Financing


Jewelry Insurance Options


Customer (link) & Non Customer (link) Referral Program $$$$


A+ BBB rating


Multiple Best of Long Island Recipient



Track Order

Returning Customers

Sign in to your account to track orders and view your order history.

Quick Track

Don't have an account? Enter your order number and email address below to track your order.