Good Old Gold is a family owned and operated business conveniently located on the south shore of Long Island in Massapequa Park, New York. Established in 1980 and online since 1998, we have been serving clients locally and online with a large selection of antique and estate jewelry, handpicked diamonds, bridal and fashion jewelry including Tacori, Michael M, D Vatche, Beverley K, Officina Bernardi and more. We also have an in house jeweler and diamond setter for all of your jewelry repair needs, from the simplest of repairs to a complete redesign of your existing pieces. We buy diamonds, gold, platinum, silver and watches which can be used toward your purchase.

From the moment you enter our store or contact us online, know we will work hard to help you make the jewelry buying decision that’s just right for you.

Diamond Concierge

Can’t find a diamond listed on our site? With our diamond concierge services we can find the perfect diamond for you. We will search the market to find the best and most brilliant diamond that fits your specifications and budget. Once we locate potential candidates, we will inspect, analyze, photograph and if necessary video the contenders side by side for you to see.

Have you found a diamond already somewhere else? We can often obtain specific diamonds on the market and include them in our diamond concierge search. Many times we can meet or beat our competitor’s prices while offering our high level of service.

Let Good Old Gold take all the guessing off the table and give you the ultimate peace of mind with this special purchase.

Custom CAD Jewelry Design

Would you like to create the perfect piece of jewelry? Work with us to design and create the piece of your dreams. Work with one of our setting specialists and we will design with you, hand in hand, the perfect piece of jewelry. Share pictures or your ideas of the piece of jewelry with us and we will create it for you. We will work with you every step of the way with CAD designs, show you the renders, then the resin model for your approval.

Top Designers

Good Old Gold carries a wide variety of designers and manufactures to fit every customer’s style and budget, including Tacori, Michael M, D Vatche, Beverley K, Elle, Meira T, Luvente and others.

We also carry one of a kind designer estate items and watches from Roberto Coin, David Yurman, Ippolita, Cartier, Tiffany & Co., and Tamara Comolli.

Financing

Good Old Gold offers 6 month interest-free financing through Synchrony Financial with longer-term special promotions throughout the year. This will allow you to spread out payments over an extended period of time.

We also offer to pay with Affirm. Affirm lets you spread out your purchase over time for a small fee.

Please contact us if you would like to further discuss the financing of your purchase, you can stop by our store or give us a call at (516) 798-5151.

We also accept checks, bank wires, Visa, MasterCard, American Express, Discover, and PayPal.

516-798-5151 Directions Track my Order Wishlist

Shopping Cart

My Account

Visit our IN STOCK JEWELRY section to view
items for immediate purchase and shipping.

Need Assistance?

516-798-5151

View All 2686 Products Engagement Rings

View All 4651 Products Wedding Bands

View All 0 Products Estate

View All 757 Products Fashion Rings

View All 452 Products Bracelets

View All 830 Products Earrings

View All 1321 Products Necklaces

View All 757 Products Designer Estate

View All 0 Products Watches

Shop All Diamonds

View more designers

Welcome to Good Old Gold

Good Old Gold was established in 1980 when John & Helen Weingarten moved their jewelry store to Massapequa Park. Since then, we have dedicated ourselves to providing the very best in jewelry, service, and diamond education. Our mission is to simplify the process of purchasing jewelry and diamonds by providing service and information that is second to none. We are proud to offer a wide selection of bridal, fine and antique jewelry, gemstones and diamonds.

Our Family Jewelry Store

Good Old Gold is a family owned and operated business established by Helen and John Weingarten in 1980 and online since 1998. Helen and John's passion for buying and selling estate jewelry and coins inspired their three children to pursue different niches in the jewelry industry. Jonathan's knowledge in diamond education, Susan's enthusiasm for gemstones, and Amy's creative custom jewelry designs together created different avenues for the business to grow and serve the customer.

Luxury Designers Available

We are proud to offer some of the finest jewelry designers in Long Island, including a wide variety of well known brands. Some of which include Michael M, Tacori and Effy. We also carry popular brands including Gabriel& Co., Stuller, Elle, Officina Bernardi, Leo Ingwer, Unique Settings of New York, Benchmark and Fredrick Goldman. We have an unbeatable selection of rings, earrings, bracelets, necklaces, and other fine jewelry items, and our bridal jewelry selection is absolutely breathtaking. We have an extensive selection of Estate and Antique jewelry and our own August Vintage brand of loose diamond and jewelry.

Our Services

We offer on premise expert jewelry repair, diamond and gemstone setting, watch repair and battery replacement, appraisals and insurance claims, ear piercing by appointment, design services including CAD, custom cutting and recutting of diamonds, consignment of designer or important pieces, purchasing of your old jewelry, coins, silverware and diamonds.

For more information on our consignment services.

Need Assistance?

Designers

Welcome to Good Old Gold

Our Family Jewelry Store

Luxury Designers Available

Our Services

All Designers

Our Company

Store address

Store HOURS

email address

telephone number

nearby cities

Track Order

Returning Customers

Quick Track

Your Cart

Need Assistance?

Designers

Welcome to Good Old Gold

Our Family Jewelry Store

Luxury Designers Available

Our Services

All Designers

Our Company

Store address

Store HOURS

email address

telephone number

nearby cities

Track Order

Returning Customers

Quick Track