Over 40 Years in Business Over 40 Years in Business
Diamond Concierge Diamond Concierge
Custom CAD Jewelry Design Custom CAD Jewelry Design
Top Designers Top Designers
Financing Financing

Visit our IN STOCK JEWELRY section to view
items for immediate purchase and shipping.

Shop All Diamonds

Welcome to Good Old Gold

Good Old Gold was established in 1980 when John & Helen Weingarten moved their jewelry store to Massapequa Park. Since then, we have dedicated ourselves to providing the very best in jewelry, service, and diamond education. Our mission is to simplify the process of purchasing jewelry and diamonds by providing service and information that is second to none. We are proud to offer a wide selection of bridal, fine and antique jewelry, gemstones and diamonds.


Our Family Jewelry Store

Good Old Gold is a family owned and operated business established by Helen and John Weingarten in 1980 and online since 1998. Helen and John's passion for buying and selling estate jewelry and coins inspired their three children to pursue different niches in the jewelry industry. Jonathan's knowledge in diamond education, Susan's enthusiasm for gemstones, and Amy's creative custom jewelry designs together created different avenues for the business to grow and serve the customer.


Luxury Designers Available

We are proud to offer some of the finest jewelry designers in Long Island, including a wide variety of well known brands. Some of which include Michael M, Tacori and Effy. We also carry popular brands including Gabriel& Co., Stuller, Elle, Officina Bernardi, Leo Ingwer, Unique Settings of New York, Benchmark and Fredrick Goldman. We have an unbeatable selection of rings, earrings, bracelets, necklaces, and other fine jewelry items, and our bridal jewelry selection is absolutely breathtaking. We have an extensive selection of Estate and Antique jewelry and our own August Vintage brand of loose diamond and jewelry.


Our Services

We offer on premise expert jewelry repair, diamond and gemstone setting, watch repair and battery replacement, appraisals and insurance claims, ear piercing by appointment, design services including CAD, custom cutting and recutting of diamonds, consignment of designer or important pieces, purchasing of your old jewelry, coins, silverware and diamonds.

For more information on our consignment services.


Track Order

Returning Customers

Sign in to your account to track orders and view your order history.

Quick Track

Don't have an account? Enter your order number and email address below to track your order.