Over 35 Years in BusinessOver 35 Years in Business
Diamond ConciergeDiamond Concierge
Lifetime Diamond UpgradesLifetime Diamond Upgrades
Custom CAD Jewelry DesignCustom CAD Jewelry Design
Top DesignersTop Designers
Financing Financing

Consignment Service

Welcome to Good Old Gold’s “Consign Your Diamond & Jewelry” service! Here’s how it works.

You have a diamond or jewelry item valued over $1,000 that you would like us to sell for you. You fill out the form at the bottom of this page so we can give an approximate estimate what you’d be able to get for your item. If you are happy with our estimate, the next step is a live evaluation. You can either ship it to us or bring it into our showroom. Once your diamond and/or jewelry arrives in our lab we will analyze it to determine what the actual fair market value is and what you will be able to get in a reasonable amount of time. If we determine that your jewelry needs any refurbishing in order to sell, such as polishing or plating, you will be responsible for the charges.

We allow the purchaser a 10-day return period, so after the purchase is made and the item is not returned within this period, we will consider the sale final and would proceed with issuing payment to you.

Reasons why Good Old Gold is an excellent choice for consigning your diamonds and jewelry.

  1. Your diamond will be published with the same analysis we provide with all of the other diamonds we list. This crucial information empowers potential buyers with the confidence that they are making a smart and informed purchase.
  2. We are a full-service jewelry store, in business since 1980, and your piece will be appropriately displayed in one of our showcases.
  3. We’ve been selling online since 1998.
  4. We have a variety of social media platforms that have a strong organic following on which to post your item, including YouTube, Instagram, and Facebook.
  5. Bottom line – your diamond or jewelry will receive great exposure on the web and in-store through us.
  6. If your jewelry needs to be refurbished in order to sell, we can take care of that in-house.

If you are interested in acquiring an estimate to consign your diamond simply fill out the form below and hit submit and someone on our staff will give a response within 48 hours.


Please understand that we do not accept all consignments. We know our clientele well and will know if the piece is appropriate for us and if we are capable of selling it. If we don’t accept your piece on consignment, we may be able to offer other selling solutions. If you are in a rush to sell, consignment may not be the best option for you.
The information you share with us IS NOT sold or given to other websites. We respect your privacy 100%.



FAQ's on Good Old Golds Consignment Service

  1. Q: How do you determine a fair retail price for my item?
    A: There are many factors we consider when determining a fair price for your items. After we complete our analysis of your item, we look at the market and find similar items (“comparisons”) and see what they are selling for and what type of service that company is offering.

  2. Q: How much does Good Old Gold make on my item?
    A: It varies from piece to piece but we make anywhere from 15 to 20 percent per item with a minimum dollar amount of $500.

  3. Q: Will you ever deny a piece for consignment?
    A: Yes, we will refuse items for consignment depending on certain criteria.

  4. Q: Will you accept my items as a trade?
    A: We do not accept items as a trade but we can offer a price to purchase.

  5. Q: What is the safest way to ship my item to you?
    A: United States Postal Service registered mail is the best and least expensive way to get your item to us. If you would like to discuss alternate shipping options, contact us.

  6. Q: Can you tell me what I can expect to get for my item?
    A: Yes, we will agree on the price and the amount you will receive before we list the item for sale.

  7. Q: How long does it take to sell my item?
    A: The time frame varies from item to item but there will always be pieces that take longer or do not sell because of style, desirability, or price. There will also be pieces that sell within a week of listing them.

  8. Q: Will I be contacted when an offer is made on my items?
    A: Yes, if an offer is made we will contact you.

  9. Q: After the sale, how long will it take for me to get paid?
    A: After the sale is complete and the customer takes delivery of the item, they have 10 days to return it. After the 10-day period expires and the item is not returned, we will issue a check to you.

  10. Q: What if I want my items back?
    A: If you would like your diamond returned back to you within one year, there is a $250 fee. After a year that amount becomes $125. The fee for other jewelry is $100, regardless of when you decide to take it back. This fee is only applied if you take your item off of consignment and does not apply if the item is sold. Return shipping and any resetting fee, if applicable, would also be additional to the fees listed above.

  11. Q: Are my items insured while in your possession?
    A: Yes, consignment items are covered for theft or loss through our Jewelers Mutual insurance policy. If anything happens to your piece, you are covered for the replacement value.

First time visit popup
First time visit popup

Track Order

Returning Customers

Sign in to your account to track orders and view your order history.

Quick Track

Don't have an account? Enter your order number and email address below to track your order.